John and Collen Baker have owned and operated Cheesy Eddie’s since 2003, when they took over the business from the original owners. And yes – their last name really is Baker! After their first few bites of Cheesy Eddie’s cheesecake at a wedding in 1989, they were hooked. They fell in love with the many incredible desserts (you’ve heard of the carrot cake, right?!) and the delicious, all-natural products, made with the finest ingredients and a personal touch. They are proud to continue the legacy of providing top quality desserts for all to enjoy. They serve carrot cakes, a wide variety of full cheesecakes and individual slices, large and mini cupcakes, tarts, and grab-and-go options (like cookie sandwiches and brownies).
And the next time you purchase a cheesecake, follow their expert advice for slicing it by using a piece of fishing line. Just hold the line tightly and draw it through. And if you’re tempted to use dental floss, don’t! Cheesy Eddie’s says the flavor can ruin a cheesecake. They’re so serious about that one that they even keep a supply of fishing line on hand at the bakery that they provide to you.
Cheesy Eddie’s has two locations – one at 602 South Avenue and the other at 900 Jefferson Road in the Regional Market (Bldg. 21, near Palmer’s). Both are open Monday-Saturday. You can also find them at the seven local and regional grocery stores and markets listed below.
- Calabresella Deli (in Gates, Rochester, Fairport, and Avon)
- Costanza’s (in Webster)
- Dell’s Market (in Greece)
- Herrema’s Market (in Irondequoit)
- Rubino’s Market (in Irondequoit)
- R’s Market (in Brighton)
- Taste of Rochester (Rochester International Airport)
Special Resident Offer
As part of our VIP program, South & Hickory Place residents receive 10% off purchases of $10 or more at Cheesy Eddie’s. You can visit them online here.